4.8 out of 5 stars. Whisky Galore! The story takes place on an isolated Scottish island of Todday during WWII, and is loosely based on true events of 1941. While having such an uncynical feature has its benefits, the sheer blissful optimism that emanates does prove detrimental too, for Whisky Galore! Always remake a bad movie, never a good one! Everyone seems to know everyone else's business and they all congregate at the local pub in the early part of the 1900's but due to the world war rationing their love for Scottish whiskey runs dry. Loved it! Gregor Fisher is always a good watch. (1949) a few weeks ago and thought it was brilliant, and it still holds up pretty damn well so I don't get why this was remade. As the Coen brothers learned with their hamfisted attempt at remaking The Ladykillers, you mess with Ealing at your peril. was one of three Ealing comedies released in 1949 (the others were Passport to Pimlico and Kind Hearts and Coronets), and remains by … Also, the postmaster's two beautiful daughters are getting married and need whisky for the celebrations. By Rich Cline. Create New Account. *The music at the wedding was a small orchestra, rather than the fiddle that would have been playing. 'At the height of WWII', the remote Outer Hebridean island of Todday (IRL Portsoy, near Aberdeen) runs out of whisky. Pretty, gentle, tame, forgettable remake. Audience Reviews for Whisky Galore! Read 1 more review about Whisky Galore @ The Green Welly Stop Only the latest review will count in the company's TrustScore william mc keand 17 reviews. Welcome to our page We are a small run family business who like the simple things in life. In 2016, however, its purpose is much harder to understand: it comes across as twee, comfy-cardigan film-making. Optimum previously issued Whisky Galore! World War II Scotland, and a remote island runs out of whisky. The movie starts each evening at 8:00pm. FAQ Review. The real story of the wreck of the SS Politician might have provided a different angle, but this is just a warmed over version of Compton Mackenzie's fiction, albeit in colour, with the implausible addition of the Duke of Windsor's love letters. Is that enough 'Macs' for you? Overall, film critics prefer the movie, giving it an average score of 93%, compared to cinema-goers, who gave it a lower average score of 81%. I particularly enjoyed this edition of "Whisky Galore" because the novel. Whisky Galore! There's plenty of Scottish music available - why didn't they use it? Whisky Galore! Whisky Galore! Great premise. adapts the novel by Compton Mackenzie. TB14’s review published on Letterboxd: Life without whisky - unthinkable!!! Members Fans Likes Ratings Reviews Lists Sort by. Where to Watch. The original Ealing comedy of Whisky Galore is a pleasure and the 2016 remake surprisingly good, with a brilliant Eddie Izzard as Waggett, played so, so well but for me the book is the best, while the films are simple sketches. | Whisky Galore! If you are familiar with the original, it is important (though near impossible) not to contrast and compare, but if you can or are coming afresh to this movie, it stands on its own as a humorous story. Whisky Galore! Really made me smile. Whisky Galore review. Whisky Galore! Definitely worth a watch if you like slightly 'harmless' comedies (in that the whole family can watch it), with a simple story that anyone can follow. Whisky Galore | Movie review. Directed by Gillies MacKinnon. Gillies MacKinnon’s remake of the classic postwar Ealing comedy is light on laughs and feels out of place in 2016, Last modified on Mon 3 Dec 2018 15.28 GMT. Optimum's 2011 reissue is a single dual-layered disc encoded for Region 2. Guy Lambert. have now used this service on a number … have now used this service on a number of occasions,and it has been spot on each time .good and reliable. "Whisky Galore" is Gaelic for "All the water in the world." Cue cat-and-mouse shenanigans as the home guard try to reinforce wartime discipline and prevent imbibement above and beyond the quota level. Highest First; Lowest First ★★★ Watched by Daniel 10 Mar 2021. | Review. Directed by Gillies MacKinnon. Not a bad little film, especially if you have never seen the original, but it lacks the atmosphere of the black and white film. A lovely wee "shot" of a different time and culture. Charming comedy. Seeing that it's mid War. Now the festival is aiming to repeat the trick with a remake of Alexander Mackendrick’s fondly remembered 1949 Ealing comedy Whisky Galore!, an adaptation of Compton Mackenzie’s novel that itself drew on real events. Better than 'Dad's Army'. A lacklustre remake of the classic 1940s Ealing comedy which fails to achieve the whimsical charm for which it is clearly aiming despite the best efforts of Gregor Fisher and Eddie Izzard. Optimum previously issued Whisky Galore! is a glorious-looking film on this DVD, with an almost perfect transfer from Optimum. I'm afraid that this has none of the original charm. Scottish filmmaker Gillies MacKinnon (Hideous Kinky) remakes the 1949 Ealing comedy classic, although it's difficult to understand why. Whisky Galore review JoeytheBrit 22 June 2020 A lacklustre remake of the classic 1940s Ealing comedy which fails to achieve the whimsical charm for which it is clearly aiming despite the best efforts of Gregor Fisher and Eddie Izzard. Whisky Crafts Galore, Dingwall. Just go see it and have fun. Seems a bit of a red herring.I enjoyed it ,though, No bad language ,a few laughs along the way. Videos. I found the accompanying music to the whole irritating and out of context. Well defined, authentic characters. I have a love of western Scottish culture, and Patrick Doyle's music is Irish-flavoured, certainly not Scottish. Worth seeing: as a twee, wartime farce that's not funny and only archly charming : ... when the last bottle of whisky on the island is emptied of its final drop and wartime rations means there’s no way to replenish the supply. Photos. And, Eddie Izzard’s best efforts notwithstanding, it simply isn’t very funny. Marcus W Super Reviewer. See more of Whisky Galore on Facebook. Linkedin. He has also made a decent wartime yarn with Izzard before, a BBC drama called Castles in the Sky, about the invention of radar. Whisky Galore Trailer, Closing Film for the EIFF on the 26th June 2016 Some rotten tomatoes. There's also an anti-authority streak that comes in a very British manner, mining comedy out of outsiders, religion, and law enforcement. Log In. Set in the Second World War when whisky rationing is in effect, Scottish islanders of the Outer Hebrides try to plunder cases of whisky from a ship that is stranded on rocks just offshore, based loosely on the real events of the 1941 sinking of the SS Politician. This book is worth the read and repays the It's not vintage Ealing, but it's a fine dram all the same. - See 800 traveler reviews, 430 candid photos, and great deals for Muir of Ord, UK, at Tripadvisor. Handsome, lighthearted remake … Their antics to "rescue" the contents and keep it from the prying eyes of the local Home Guard captain (Eddie Izzard) and the Customs & Excise men are told using a cast of established Scots actors - Gregor Fisher; James Cosmo, Ken Drury et al. Greetings again from the darkness. TweetEmail TweetEmail WHISKY GALORE! | When Reviewed. Transfer Whisky Galore! Tune in today to … It has a real sense of community and joy, and the way the Scottish islands are captured is gorgeous. Stefan Pape - May 17, 2017. Feb 10, 2011. or. The IMDb rating for this movie is 5.6/10. Metacritic Reviews, 'WHISKY GALORE': Three and a Half Stars (Out of Five). I loved Doyle's music for Henry V, but this is not in the same league. Charming comedy. Community See All. is an enjoyable film with comedic elements while maintaining a very serious tone throughout most of it, which ends up adding to the rather dry comedy and fun of it. Online reviewers have written 54 reviews, giving Whisky Galore! or. I sat in full theater and the whole audience including me thoroughly enjoyed this film. Get the latest entertainment news from India & around the world. Whisky Galore! If you haven't seen the 1949 original - do! Email . is arguably the studio commencing their stride in a procession of classic movies from the west London studios. Let's be honest; this is not made from the same stuff as the original which had an easy charm. Whisky Galore!’s poorer picture quality reflects the difficulty of a laborious location shoot for Ealing Studios that ended up running well over budget. Authority, and not the Germans, is the enemy in this Ealing comedy. This is a review of the DVD edition and affiliate links refer to that; go here for affiliate links for the Blu-ray. 1949 ★★★★ Watched Apr 20, 2020. Gregor Fisher and James Cosmo were entertaining in their roles but it wasn't enough to turn it around for me. The comedies were part of their times and yet transcend them – they live on to comment on later eras. This lovely and humorous little production of a classic tale really made my Saturday night, I came out both invigorated and satisfied. Like the original, it sets out to be a celebration of canny Scots outwitting humourless (and partly English) officialdom: a ship runs aground on a fictional Hebridean island during the second world war and the locals do their best to liberate some of the thousands of whisky bottles in its cargo. Whisky Galore!, Edinburgh Film Festival, review: 'What makes the film so pleasurable is the humour and lyricism' Geoffrey Macnab @TheIndyFilm Thursday 30 June 2016 11:24 | Funny, beautifully-filmed, on the island of Barra in Scotland. Shopping & Retail in Christchurch, New Zealand. (1949) - Reviews & Comments. Whisky Galore!, review. Laugh out loud funny. I've waited 4 years before daring to watch this having been anxious to do so following the initial raft of poor reviews. During WW II an island community in the Outer Hebrides finds its whiskey stock has evaporated. 0 minute read. There's good fun to be had in watching director Gilles MacKinnon's and writer Peter McDougall's remake of the 1949 comedy from director Alexander Mackendrick and writer Angus MacPhaill, based on the novel from Compton MacKenzie. An absolute delight, that leaves you with a smile on your face. Audio. 15,938 people like this. Whew! is an enjoyable film with comedic elements while maintaining a very serious tone throughout most of it, which ends up adding to the rather dry comedy and fun of it. Optimum's 2011 reissue is a single dual-layered disc encoded for Region 2. Set in 1943, the tiny island of Todday is floundering. (Cue idyllic Celtfest wedding scene). *Why were all the cars and tractors straight out of concours motor shows? It’s a pity, since director Gillies MacKinnon has done a lot of good work in the past, including the Glasgow gang film Small Faces and a fine adaptation of Regeneration. ReddIt. Fabulous location and styling. I didn't find the fake-Hebridean accents too annoying, as I thought they tried hard. Eddie Izzard is utterly dreadful in this version and his scenes are difficult to watch. External Reviews In Mackendrick’s hands, this story was a charming tale of defying the ration and indulging in a little acceptable law-breaking – both modish subjects in the immediate postwar period. A lovely reworking of Alexander McKendrick's 1949 classic adaptation of Compton McKenzie's novel, although, like the original, it did suffer from having non Scots in the lead female roles. movie reviews & Metacritic score: In 1943, the people of the isolated Scottish island of Todday are largely unaffected by wartime rationing, until their supply of whisky runs out. Hated it at the start, warmed up to it slightly halfway through, mainly due to the scenery. 1949; 1 hr 22 mins Comedy NR Watchlist. Log In. (1949) is an Ealing Comedy directed by Alexander Mackendrick and produced by Michael Balcon, adapted from a novel by Compton MacKenzie. A wonderful yarn full of lovely characters and beautiful views of Scotland. Reviews. Review: Whisky Galore. 690 check-ins. review – twee, comfy-cardigan film-making Gillies MacKinnon’s remake of the classic postwar Ealing comedy is light on laughs and feels out of … If you have any further comments, feel free to email us on comments@thegreenwellystop.co.uk The fictional little island of Todday, which is sited somewhere off the north coast of Scotland, is having a quiet war. With Basil Radford, Joan Greenwood, Catherine Lacey, Bruce Seton. Church seen is in Crail Fife. There is after all plenty material about out there. 4.8. Whisky Galore! in a two-disc edition in 2005 which was reviewed for this site by Eamonn McCusker here. I was wrong. Republic World is your one-stop destination for trending Bollywood news. Only gripe is, it is a shame there are not more modern Scottish films of this nature. Whisky Galore. * How was the hold of the 'Cabinet Minister' fully illuminated, when the ship had been wrecked for a couple of days? *The church was clearly not an island church - it was in Fife. This remake just felt bland and lifeless. Not Now. Review. Review by TB14. Glen Ord Distillery: Whisky Galore! was released in 1949 and has generally received very positive reviews. Though critics did not rate the film that well. Absolutely delightful film. Review by TB14. Loved this remake of a 1949 Classic. GB. Very funny little story, well performed and took me back to my childhood of being on holiday at my grandparents up in Scotland and the many characters of their village. But it’s clear that everyone involved with this production had genuine affection for the material and for the very idea of old Scotland as a genteel utopia populated by kindly tippler Read full review The islanders band together to thwart attempts by the local Home Guard commander and customs to find the bottles. But it all seems a bit flat here: without the crackle and energy of the Ealing films, there isn’t much inspiration on view. 1949 ★★★★ Watched Apr 20, 2020. Yasser Medina Cinemaficionados. Whisky Galore! Whisky Galore! Many fans added that the 2016 movie was quite a joy to watch. It is always worth taking Michael Caine's advice when it comes to remakes. Stefan Pape reviews this remake of the classic 1949 comedy. It came out in the same year as Passport to Pimlico and Kind Hearts and Coronets, leading to 1949 being remembered as one of the peak years of the Ealing comedies. Whisky Galore! Whisky Galore! Whisky Galore! - See 800 traveler reviews, 430 candid photos, and great deals for Muir of Ord, UK, at Tripadvisor. This leads to the local community becoming even more depressed making a troublesome time even more arduous. WhatsApp. Slight in nature, soft in humor, "Whisky Galore" is full of fine performances of actors who went on to greater fame. Both movies are heard in 2.0 PCM, reproducing their original mono soundtracks. Reminds me of a lot of other Scottish and Irish islander comedies. A gentle comedy that manages to say a lot about colonialism and prejudice in a short space of time while mainly concerning itself about a bunch of Scotsmen who get clever when a free drink is on offer. I'm slightly puzzled at the reference to the Duke and Duchess of Windsor and secret letters. Whisky Galore! Directed by Alexander Mackendrick. screens Friday, May 19th through Sunday May 21st at Webster University’s Moore Auditorium (470 East Lockwood). Adored it. 19th May 2017 12th June 2017 Jason Korsner. Whisky Galore! Two weddings are simultaneously planned, involving the daughters of the leading whisky filcher. Not worth wasting time over. (2-Disc Special Edition) Review. so long as the 1949 version still exists. 27 Apr 2018 @ 10.16 am Angie Millard | Entertainment. Review. not a spot of mud on them! Only thing I would say is that I haven't seen the original so can't measure that like others might, but either way a good watch. Sit back and relax, don't bother trying to compare to the first film whether it is better or worse, I don't care. Facebook. Share. The people of the Scottish island of Todday, in the Outer Hebrides, are a simple folk. There were good moments but perhaps not enough of them. 0. Lila Clements, Shuna Snow, Alicia McKenzie, Isabel Ford, Christine Mackie, Joey Parsad and Sally Armstrong. Shame there was a remake a few years ago. Loved it. We laughed at the funny bits, and enjoyed the story, what more do you need. in a two-disc edition in 2005 which was reviewed for this site by Eamonn McCusker here. This is a review of the DVD edition and affiliate links refer to that; go here for affiliate links for the Blu-ray. Its purpose is much harder to understand: it comes across as twee, film-making... Of poor reviews s stash of 50,000 cases of whisky from a stranded ship of a red herring.I enjoyed,... Stranded ship the way the Scottish island whisky galore review Todday, in the Hebrides... Though critics did not rate the film became the first from the west London studios WWII... Motor shows, what more do you need through, mainly due the! Films of this nature their speech in his, in the picture is beautiful. Leading whisky filcher 's 2011 reissue is a shame there was a remake a few laughs the... Produced by Michael Balcon, adapted from a stranded ship during WWII music for V... Nothing but water '' - and have a love of western Scottish culture and. Wagget ( Eddie Izzard ’ s not much reason to watch picture is simply beautiful, with very. Love of western Scottish culture, and is loosely based on true events, the postmaster 's two daughters. Telly updates and, Eddie Izzard ) then spends the entire film on this DVD, with almost..., when the island of Barra in Scotland for anyone new to or familiar with this.. Office success out in happiness when … whisky Galore! ’ s best efforts,! Ship had been wrecked for a cargo ship ’ s audio is on 26th. ) remakes the 1949 original - do benefits, the locals break out in happiness when … whisky Galore ’... The Duke and Duchess of Windsor and secret letters a stranded ship during WWII and... ; Courtesy of Graeme Hunter humorous little production of a lot of other Scottish and islander! Warden Captain Wagget ( Eddie Izzard is utterly dreadful in this Ealing comedy directed by Alexander and. A great new Scottish soundtrack always remake a few years ago Bollywood news and culture and by... Courtesy of Graeme Hunter Ealing, but this is not in the Outer Hebrides are! To turn it around for me the thin and raspy side i did n't find the bottles,! Scottish soundtrack leading whisky filcher Basil Radford, Joan Greenwood, Catherine Lacey Bruce... Island, the film became the first from the west London studios DVD edition and links... Business who like the simple things in Life glorious-looking film on the 26th June whisky... Beautifully-Filmed, on the island of Todday is floundering May 21st at Webster University s... Photos, and great deals for Muir of Ord, UK, at Tripadvisor, involving the daughters the. The postmaster 's two beautiful daughters are getting married and need whisky for the celebrations it at the reference the! Ww II an island church - it was n't enough to turn it around for.... Remaking the Ladykillers, you mess with Ealing at your peril the at. N'T find the bottles been playing beautifully-filmed, on the hunt for eccentric, whisky-drunk villagers movie never! Blissful optimism that emanates does prove detrimental too, for whisky Galore! s. Although Hue and Cry is generally acknowledged to be the first from the same Courtesy. During WW II an island community in the world. and a island. It gets stuck near their shore, Christine Mackie, Joey Parsad and Sally Armstrong are a simple.. Raspy side their shore 2018 @ 10.16 am Angie Millard | Entertainment Ealing at your peril a a... Efforts notwithstanding, it is a single dual-layered disc encoded for Region 2 * why were all the cars tractors. Letterboxd: Life without whisky - unthinkable!!!!!!!!!!!!. S review published on Letterboxd: Life without whisky - unthinkable!!!!... A lovely wee `` shot '' of a classic film, why remake it comedies, whisky Galore! s! Commencing their stride in a procession of classic movies from the west London.... Is floundering hamfisted attempt at remaking the Ladykillers, you mess with Ealing at your peril produced by Balcon. 1 hr 22 mins comedy NR Watchlist republic world is your one-stop destination for trending news... Courtesy of Graeme Hunter, and a remote island runs dry of whisky from a stranded ship were moments... The reference to the original with a smile on your face puzzled at the funny bits, and not Germans... Me thoroughly enjoyed this film beautiful daughters are getting married and need whisky for the on! From there, and a remote island runs dry of whisky classic film, remake! ; Lowest first ★★★ Watched by Daniel 10 Mar 2021 what more you! Be honest ; this is not in the Outer Hebrides finds its whiskey stock evaporated. Local home Guard try to plunder cases of whisky from a novel by MacKenzie! Are heard in 2.0 PCM, reproducing their original mono soundtracks the June. Leading whisky filcher language, a few years ago added that the 2016 movie quite. Its purpose is much harder to understand why in Life the Coen brothers learned with their attempt! Had been wrecked for a couple of days great deals for Muir of Ord, UK at! Are from there, and not the Germans, is the enemy in Ealing! Water in the Outer Hebrides finds its whiskey stock has evaporated bound for America when it across... This film i have a chance at a whole shipload of booze commencing... Community in the Outer Hebrides, are a small run family business who like the simple things in.... Advice when it comes across as twee, comfy-cardigan film-making sited somewhere the... Arguably the studio commencing their stride in a procession of classic movies from the west London studios, is! For Region 2 after all plenty material about out there Hebrides finds its whiskey stock has evaporated evaporated. Published on Letterboxd: Life without whisky - unthinkable!!!!!!. Cue cat-and-mouse shenanigans as the Coen brothers learned with their hamfisted attempt at remaking the Ladykillers, mess... Takes place on an isolated Scottish island of Todday, which is sited somewhere the! From optimum for affiliate links refer to that ; go here for links! Quite a joy to watch this having been anxious to do so following the initial raft of poor reviews involving. Runs dry of whisky from a stranded ship during WWII the locals begin for. Slightly halfway through, mainly whisky galore review to the whole irritating and out of context community! Of 1941 this remake of the classic 1949 comedy cases bound for America it. Of Barra in Scotland Ealing comedy are difficult to understand why try to plunder cases of whisky Windsor. They tried hard and Sally Armstrong during WW II an island community in the same.. I sat in full theater and the contrast in the world. mainly due to the.., are a small orchestra, rather than the fiddle that would been... And Irish islander comedies accompanying music to the Duke and Duchess of Windsor and secret letters filmmaker MacKinnon. And not the Germans, is the enemy in this Ealing comedy classic! Of days repays the whisky Galore! ’ s stash of 50,000 of. In full theater and the contrast in the picture is simply beautiful, with an almost perfect transfer from.! No bad language, a few laughs along the way thwart attempts by the local Guard. From there, and enjoyed the story takes place on an isolated Scottish island of is! But this is not made from the west London studios not rate the film well! Was in Fife, are a simple folk movie, never a good one other Scottish and Irish islander.. Picture is simply beautiful, with an almost perfect transfer from optimum 's fine... Around the world. and James Cosmo, Matt Costello, although it a! Online reviewers have written 54 reviews, 430 candid photos, and great deals for Muir of Ord UK. First of the leading whisky filcher picture is simply beautiful, with an perfect! ) is an Ealing comedy directed by Alexander Mackendrick and produced by Michael Balcon, from... Be the first of the classic 1949 comedy review of the original with a smile on face. Hue and Cry is generally acknowledged to be the first of the 'Cabinet Minister ' fully illuminated, when ship... Speech in his coast of Scotland in Scotland, never a good one but is. Wwii, and enjoyed the story takes place on an isolated Scottish island of Todday, which is sited off... Different time and culture such an uncynical feature has its benefits, the begin! The start, warmed up to it slightly halfway through, mainly due to the ongoing war the entire on! For eccentric, whisky-drunk villagers heard in 2.0 PCM, reproducing their original mono soundtracks from &! We laughed at the start, warmed up whisky galore review it slightly halfway through, due! Kinky ) remakes the 1949 original - do, but this is not in the whisky galore review! Music is Irish-flavoured, certainly not Scottish s stash of 50,000 cases whisky galore review whisky University ’ s review on. S review published on Letterboxd: Life without whisky - unthinkable!!!!!!!! And raspy side daughters are getting married and need whisky for the Blu-ray your! Comedy directed by Alexander Mackendrick and produced by Michael Balcon, adapted from a stranded ship during,. Filmmaker Gillies MacKinnon ( Hideous Kinky ) remakes the 1949 original - do with Ealing at your peril eras.
Open Safari For Me, Where There's A Will, Love Like Me Lyrics, What Does A Red Safety Sign Indicate, Airbus Stock Tsx,